Michael Kaiser Criticises The Way Arts Managements Approach ‘Structural Deficit!’

An interesting article in the Huffington Post Arts & Culture Blog. Former ROH boss Michael Kaiser is quite damning of the negative way Arts boards & managements take to looking at re-structuring debt etc…

Michael Kaiser, “… It provides a guilt-free excuse to do less to achieve the organization’s mission.”

Michael Kaiser

President, John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts


Structural Deficits

Posted: 10/07/2013 8:10 am
As more and more arts organizations have difficulty balancing their budgets, I have heard an increasing discussion of structural deficits. The notion is that there is a built in deficit to the way the organization operates; that the sum of earned and contributed income simply cannot reach the level of expenses of the organization as it is currently configured. The term is used to defend radical reductions in organization size, salaries and ambition. If an organization faces a structural deficit, it simply must do less work, pay lower salaries, reduce staff size, etc. In other words, it must aim lower.

Having spent most of my arts management career working to erase deficits of arts organizations, I must suggest that most organizations that face deficits do not facestructural deficits. A structural deficit is one that is built into the model for an arts organization. It can only be eliminated by a radical restructuring.

Many symphony orchestras today believe they have structural deficits and are, therefore, attempting to reduce work weeks, or reduce musicians’ salaries dramatically. The ongoing tragedy of the Minnesota Orchestra is just one case in point of an organization that is attempting to reduce costs dramatically in the name of erasing a structural deficit.

But I think the term is overused, and misused, and is simply a cop out in most situations. It allows a group to rationalize reducing fundraising and ticket sales requirements. It provides a guilt-free excuse to do less to achieve the organization’s mission.

Arts organizations may be earning deficits but they are doing so because they have not created the art, pursued the marketing, built the boards, or created the fundraising mechanisms that are required to sustain the organization.

I can point to dozens of arts organizations that are balancing their budgets. Why can they balance their budgets while others in the same art form cannot? Why don’t they have structural deficits when they have the same structure as their less fortunate counterparts?

Almost always the answer can be found in strong management and a good strategy. The Miami City Ballet had been earning deficits and last year it turned the corner. So have numerous other organizations. Each of these organizations faced their problems, developed a strong plan, engaged in aggressive fundraising and marketing programs and is now poised for greater success and accomplishment.

How sad it would be if during the bad years, the boards of these organizations had decided to radically downsize, to reduce the ambitions of the organization, to cut staff and artist salaries and to become less important institutions. How many fewer audience members would be entertained? How many fewer children would be educated? How many fewer works of art would be created?

There are organizations with structural deficits, to be sure. But they are few and far between. Many more simply need to rethink the strategies they have developed, the art they are producing, the strength of their marketing efforts, the composition of their boards and the way they welcome new donors to the institution.

About brendanball

Professional Trumpeter: Soloist, Orchestra Player, Chamber Music, Contemporary Music & Education.
This entry was posted in About Brendan Ball and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s